← Back to Journal

Broker Fee in NYC: Who Pays Under the FARE Act (2026)?

May 1, 2026 · seobruv
Broker Fee in NYC: Who Pays Under the FARE Act (2026)?

So who actually pays the broker fee NYC apartments are so famous for these days? Under the new FARE Act rules, it’s simple: whoever hires the broker pays them. For most renters, that means the landlord covers their own agent’s commission, not you. A broker fee is just the commission paid to an agent for finding a tenant, but for generations, that basic logic got flipped on its head here.

Historically, New York was one of the only markets in the country where landlords hired the agents, but tenants got stuck footing the bill at signing. It never made much sense, honestly, imagine paying the chef a restaurant owner hired. The FARE Act finally fixed that in almost every typical rental situation.

Let’s walk through what changed, the few exceptions worth knowing, and what it actually means for you as a renter or landlord in 2026.

What Is the FARE Act and Why Was It Passed?

For decades, moving to New York meant clearing a real financial hurdle: renters often paid thousands of dollars to agents they never even hired. The Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act, the FARE Act, under which NYC landlords and renters now live, was passed to fix exactly that, bringing some basic fairness to a process that had gotten pretty absurd, and aligning the city with how the rest of the country handles this.

Before the law, landlords routinely hired brokers to list their units and conduct showings, then passed the entire cost on to whoever ended up signing the lease. It created a real barrier for everyday renters trying to move. The new rules officially took effect on June 11, 2025, and apply across all five boroughs, so whether you’re looking at Manhattan listings or hunting in Queens, the core idea stays the same: whoever hires the agent pays the agent.

Are Broker Fees Still Legal in NYC?

Here’s a misconception we hear constantly: that commissions got banned outright. So, are broker’s fees legal in NYC right now? Yes, completely. What changed isn’t whether fees exist, but who’s on the hook for them.

The FARE Act never stopped brokers from earning a living or landlords from hiring help. It just stopped landlords from passing their own hiring costs down to tenants. Landlords can still use brokers freely, and brokers can still charge for their work.

Are broker’s fees legal in NYC even with all this change? Absolutely, landlords have just started building that commission into the advertised rent instead, or occasionally adjusting application fees where the law allows it. Because of that shift, transparency matters more than ever: agents are required to clearly disclose who’s actually paying their commission before they ever show you a unit. Even though you’re not paying the landlord’s agent anymore, you might still notice the ripple effect in slightly different pricing across listings.

Renter paying cash broker fee to real estate agent at NYC brokerage office

Who Pays the Broker Fee Now Under the FARE Act?

The golden rule here is genuinely simple. If you’re wondering who pays broker fees in NYC, it always comes down to who started the hiring process. Most of the time, the landlord hires a listing agent to market the apartment and run tours, and under the current rules, the landlord pays that agent directly.

There’s one real exception worth knowing, though. You’ll still pay a broker fee that NYC agents charge if you’re the one who hires your own representation. Too busy to hunt for apartments yourself? Bring on a tenant’s broker to build you a shortlist, schedule tours, and negotiate on your behalf, and yes, that’s on you to pay.

Here’s a quick example that makes it click. You find an online listing for a place in Brooklyn and message the agent who posted it to book a tour. That agent works for the landlord, so the landlord pays them. But if you instead call an agency and say “help me find a Brooklyn apartment,” you’ve just hired them yourself, and you’ll owe their commission at signing. That distinction matters a lot: it protects renters from the old predatory setup while still letting anyone hire real help if they want it.

How Much Are Broker Fees in NYC?

If you do decide to bring on your own tenant rep, you’re probably wondering how much broker fees are these days. There’s no fixed government number here; the amount varies by broker, firm, and the complexity of your search.

Most renters run into one of two structures: a percentage of annual rent, or a flat fee equal to one month’s rent. Since you’re the one doing the hiring, the whole NYC apartment broker fee is negotiable; you and your agent should agree on the rate upfront, before any showings start.

Worth keeping in mind: a good tenant rep genuinely earns that fee. They filter out bad listings, handle the paperwork, and negotiate lease terms on your behalf. Working with an established brokerage like REAL New York means you get clear fee disclosure before committing to anything, no surprises at the signing table, and no lingering confusion about who pays the broker fee in NYC in your specific case.

What This Means for Renters Searching in NYC

Apartment hunting takes a bit more attention to detail than it used to, honestly. A few things worth keeping in mind while you search:

  • Read every listing carefully.

  • Ask exactly who pays the broker fee in NYC before you agree to tour a unit.

  • Don’t assume the old rules still apply just because a listing looks familiar.

Even with the FARE Act NYC protections in place, some outdated listings still show incorrect fee info; it happens more than you’d think. Working with a local brokerage that actually understands the current landscape helps you navigate it with confidence, and it means you only ever pay for services you actually asked for. It’s also worth browsing current listings with this in mind, since fee transparency is one more thing worth checking before you fall for a unit.

Whether you’re trying to avoid a broker fee NYC landlords are now responsible for, or you’d rather have dedicated help finding the right place, reach out to REAL New York. Search our current listings or get in touch directly with any questions about your search; we’re here to keep the process as stress-free and transparent as possible.

FAQ: Broker Fees and the FARE Act in NYC

Do I have to pay a broker fee if I don’t hire a broker? 

No, not at all. The whole point of the update was to prevent exactly this. Under the FARE Act NYC rules, the person who agreed to work with the agent is the one responsible for paying them.

Can landlords raise the monthly rent to cover their costs? 

Yes, and plenty have adjusted their pricing accordingly. To offset the broker fee, NYC property owners now cover themselves; they’re allowed to raise the advertised rent. You might pay a bit more per month, but you save on the upfront cash at signing.

Is it true that real estate commissions were banned? 

No, that’s a common myth worth clearing up. Are broker fees legal in NYC? Yes, completely. The law simply requires that whoever hires the broker pays.

Does this new law apply to all five boroughs?

Yes, renters are protected everywhere across the city. The FARE Act applies equally in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island; the rules about who pays don’t vary from borough to borough.

{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "FAQPage", "mainEntity": [ { "@type": "Question", "name": "Do I have to pay a broker fee if I don’t hire a broker?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "No, not at all. The whole point of the update was to prevent exactly this. Under the FARE Act NYC rules, the person who agreed to work with the agent is the one responsible for paying them." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Can landlords raise the monthly rent to cover their costs?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Yes, and plenty have adjusted their pricing accordingly. To offset the broker fee, NYC property owners now cover themselves; they’re allowed to raise the advertised rent. You might pay a bit more per month, but you save on the upfront cash at signing." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Is it true that real estate commissions were banned?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "No, that’s a common myth worth clearing up. Are broker fees legal in NYC? Yes, completely. The law simply requires that whoever hires the broker pays." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Does this new law apply to all five boroughs?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Yes, renters are protected everywhere across the city. The FARE Act applies equally in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island; the rules about who pays don’t vary from borough to borough." } } ] }